The specification often details above and below the line criteria.
Above the line characteristics – qualities, how it looks, image, the visual interface
between user and product, materials, ergonomics, anthropometrics and function.
Below the line characteristics – product performance, how it operates, manufacture,
material and components, assembly and build quality.
Qualitative testing and quantitative testing must be considered when selecting materials
and processes for the design and manufacture of products and when writing design
specifications. Quantitative testing are objective, measurable criteria, which can
be assessed against specific performance measurable objectives such as:
The material must weigh no more than…..
The material used must be light enough to….
Related to material hardness, malleability, ductility…..
Qualitative testing will reflect the intended quality of certain defined aspects
of a material’s specification. They are a more subjective form of criteria such as
The material must be aesthetically pleasing…
Material used must be recyclable…
The material must be bright…
Consideration of market sectors.
Write down if the criteria is either quantitative (measurable) or qualitative?